Type to search

Sam Zell: Focus on Brazil, Mexico

Mexico and Brazil continue to offer strong potential for real estate, especially housing, Sam Zell argues.

[email protected]

Look for countries with strong middle-class growth -- say, China or Brazil. Stick mainly to housing and retail. Focus on the long term. And don't attempt to do it without a local partner.

That was the consensus among the global real estate developers, investors, finance specialists and executives who spoke at the recent [email protected] Real Estate in Emerging Markets Forum. With the economy in a tailspin and demand drying up in the U.S. and Western Europe, it's not surprising that real estate investors are more attracted to emerging markets than ever before.

In the U.S., for example, housing starts are at an all-time low -- down 2.7 percent in December, according to Bloomberg -- and builders have seen their share values drop 76 percent since the housing bubble burst. In early January, research firm Reis reported that mall vacancies have reached a 10-year high and are likely to go up as more stores claim bankruptcy and close their doors following six consecutive months of declining sales in 2008.   


Now it seems that the unstoppable consumer demand and high returns once guaranteed by "hypergrowth" markets like the fabled BRICs -- Brazil, Russia, India and China -- are no longer a given, either. Although the Forum panelists and speakers saw value in individual markets, they agreed that the "decoupling" hypothesis -- the notion that emerging markets can maintain growth independently of any major disruptions in the U.S. economy -- has proven to be untrue. In fact, as one panelist noted, the current situation would be more accurately described as "turbo-coupling."

Ignatius Chithelen, managing partner of New York investment firm Banyan Tree Capital, pointed out that between 2003 and 2007, the Standard & Poor's Index rose by 80 percent, and during the same period, the MSCI Emerging Markets Index was up nearly 400 percent. "Today, the U.S. market is down 50 percent, and emerging markets are down 60 percent to 70 percent. This isn't decoupling.... Very simply, when [the U.S. market] goes up, it goes up much higher in emerging markets, and when it goes down, it goes down much worse."

Chithelen noted that the BRIC classification was originally developed for marketing purposes. "You can't view these markets as one single entity. Each one needs to be judged individually according to the underlying fundamentals." Within the BRIC classification, for example, China stands apart "as the world's banker," he said, citing the country's $4 trillion in reserves, its trade and budget surpluses, and its ability to allocate huge resources to infrastructure projects. "Today, [China] is the best-situated country."


Because it has been singled out as the world's fastest-growing economy, China is perhaps the poster child for the kind of trouble that may lie ahead for emerging markets. Far from being immune to the ongoing recession in the U.S., China has seen a dramatic drop in exports, and manufacturing job losses are on the rise, numbering close to four million so far. In mid January, Fitch Ratings issued a statement that China's economy will experience a "hard landing" in 2009, with growth estimated at 6 percent. (A growth rate below 8 percent is considered a recession by the Chinese government.)

The economic uncertainty has filtered down to the real estate sector -- particularly in housing, where consumers' lack of confidence is being felt. According to the January 16 edition of China Daily, housing prices are likely "to see a huge downward pressure" as prospective buyers put their purchasing plans on hold. Meanwhile, the government has asked developers to lower prices to stimulate sales, and large developers are cutting back on the floor area of new projects -- some by as much as 30 percent to 40 percent -- to hedge against any reductions in sales.

But despite current ills, China does have one thing that several participants viewed as critical for evaluating investments in emerging markets: its huge population of 1.4 billion people, which, long term, will fuel the demand for affordable housing and retail. "GDP [growth] will ultimately follow population," said Philip Mintz, managing director of Warburg Pincus Asia in Hong Kong. Selecting a market with long-term prospects for growth and choosing the right asset class can give a "semblance of decoupling," Mintz noted, because the investment is driven by macroeconomic trends, not by current market forces.


In fact, Warburg Pincus recently launched a $1.5 billion fund with 75 percent focused on Asia. Of that amount, 60 percent is focused on China where Warburg Pincus has invested in existing, stabilized assets with only 40 percent to 50 percent leverage. It has also started businesses from scratch. "You couldn't do [the latter] in the United States," Mintz said. "The U.S. is not a growth market."

Sam Zell, chairman of Equity Group Investments and Equity International, who spoke as part of a keynote panel, underscored that point as he offered his take on various emerging markets. When asked why he would look to invest in emerging markets like Egypt or Mexico versus the United States or Europe, Zell responded, "The answer is demand." When the world begins to recover from the current economic turmoil, he said, the populations in these regions will be looking to fill their basic needs first, like housing. That's not the case in markets like the U.S., Japan and Western Europe, where "the only play has been to leverage things up." And although growth in emerging markets has slowed considerably "from 100 percent to 60 percent, that's still 60 percent [growth] over zero."


In addition to projects developing affordable housing in Cairo and in Mexico, Zell's Equity International is focusing heavily on Brazil, which he singled out as a particularly strong opportunity for investment. Like Mexico, Brazil subsidizes low-income mortgages, so consumer access to financing has been largely unaffected by the markets. The country also has "unlimited [natural] resources," and, unlike Mexico, a strong executive talent pool to help outside investors achieve scale in operations. On the retail side, Zell noted that store sales are up 12 percent from last year in the malls owned by his group -- a stark contrast to the recent U.S. figures. "If you look at all of the facts, I don't think there's another environment in the world that's better than Brazil."

According to Tom Shapiro, president and founder of GoldenTree InSite Partners, a New York-based real estate investment firm, Brazil is not seeing the distress found in other markets. Mortgages account for only 2 percent of GDP in Brazil, he noted, versus 65 percent in the United States and 74 percent in the UK, so consumers aren't feeling the effects of credit contraction. Demand is high, and unlike other markets which have seen rampant speculation, there hasn't been any overdevelopment. Shapiro said that his firm typically sees 40 percent to 50 percent of condominium units in a given complex sold within two weeks. Recently, GoldenTree sold 70 percent of the units in an office project in Sao Paulo in only 10 days.

In Brazil, real estate purchases require 15 percent cash up front and a 1 percent monthly pay-down on the principal. If the financial crisis has a wider impact, Shapiro said, market growth may slow among middle class homeowners, who don't receive government subsidies for mortgages. (...)

Although several untapped markets may look attractive, at present there is enough to do in those markets that are open to and support development activity -- such as China and Brazil. "Who wants to take their money where they aren't wanted?" Zell asked. "I don't see any reason to invest [in a market] unless I see sufficient premium to reflect the complexity and effort."

Republished with permission from http://www.knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu -- the online research and business analysis journal of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.


To read this post, you must purchase a Latin Trade Business Intelligence Subscription.
Scroll to top of page
Begin Zoho Tracking Code for Analytics